Solid-state NMR has been used to study mixed-matrix membranes (MMMs) prepared with a metal–organic framework (MOF, UiO-66) and two different high molecular weight polymers (PEO and PVDF). 13C and 1H NMR data provide overwhelming evidence that most UiO-66 organic linkers are within 1 nm of PEO, which indicates that PEO is homogeneously distributed throughout the MOF. Systematic changes in MOF 13C NMR peak positions and 1H NMR line widths, as well as dramatic reductions in the MOF 1H T1ρ relaxation times, are observed as the PEO content increases, and when the pores have been filled, a further increase in PEO results in the formation of semicrystalline PEO outside the UiO-66 particles. In contrast, similar studies on PVDF MMMs show that the polymer contacts only a small fraction (<20%) of the MOF linkers. Simulations confirm that PEO penetrates into UiO-66 more easily than does PVDF. These studies are among the first to provide experimental insights into MOF–polymer interactions in an MMM.