Pré-Publication, Document De Travail Année : 2024

Universal scaling law in turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection with and without roughness

Résumé

Experimental heat-transfer measurements published in the literature seem to be contradictory, some showing a transition of the Nu(Ra) behaviour at Ra≈10^11, some showing a delayed transition at higher Ra, or no transition at all. The physical origin of this discrepancy remains elusive, but is hypothesized to be a signature of the multiple possible flow configurations for a given set of control parameters, as well as the sub-critical nature of the transition to the ultimate regime. New experimental and numerical heat-flux and velocity measurements, both reaching Ra up to 10^12, are reported on a wide range of operating conditions, with either smooth boundaries, or mixed smooth-rough boundaries. Experiments are run in water or fluorocarbon, and aspect ratios 1 or 2. Numerical simulations implement the Boussinesq equations in a closed rectangular cavity with a Prandtl number 4.4, close to the experimental setup, also with smooth boundaries, or mixed smooth-rough boundaries. In the new measurements in the rough part of the cell, the Nusselt number is compatible with a Ra^(1/2) scaling (with logarithmic corrections), hinting a purely inertial regime. In contrast to the Nu v Ra relationship, we evidence that these seemingly different regimes can be reconciled: the heat-flux, expressed as the flux Rayleigh number, RaNu, recovers a universal scaling with Reynolds number, which collapses all data, both our own and those in the literature, once a universal critical Reynolds number is exceeded. This universal collapse can be related to the universal dissipation anomaly, observed in many turbulent flows.

Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
universal.pdf (4.04 Mo) Télécharger le fichier
Origine Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s)

Dates et versions

hal-04434081 , version 1 (02-02-2024)
hal-04434081 , version 2 (11-07-2024)
hal-04434081 , version 3 (27-05-2025)
hal-04434081 , version 4 (06-10-2025)

Identifiants

  • HAL Id : hal-04434081 , version 4

Citer

Lyse Brichet, Nathan Carbonneau, Elian Bernard, Romane Braun, Lucas Méthivier, et al.. Universal scaling law in turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection with and without roughness. 2025. ⟨hal-04434081v4⟩
3055 Consultations
594 Téléchargements

Partager

  • More